Marion Police Officer files affidavit seeking Judge Anderson’s disqualification

MARION, OH (MARION COUNTY NOW)—Brendan Damron, a Marion City police officer, has filed an affidavit seeking the disqualification of Judge Todd Anderson from presiding over his ongoing criminal case.

Officer Damron, 24, of the Marion Police Department, is being held on a $250,000 bond after being charged with two counts of rape and one count of abduction. Damron was taken into custody on February 13 in connection with an alleged off-duty incident that reportedly occurred at a private residence on February 11.

In the affidavit to disqualify, Damron alleges that Anderson’s impartiality could be compromised due to actual bias and conflicts of interest arising from personal relationships involving the judge, the alleged victim, and local law enforcement officials. 

The affidavit outlines several specific points of concern, including Judge Anderson’s close personal ties with the alleged victim, who is reportedly the wife of Damron. 

It states that the judge’s daughters were friends with the alleged victim during their childhood, suggesting a personal bond that may influence the judge’s perspective in the case.

Additionally, Damron points to Anderson’s relationships with key local law enforcement figures, including Jay McDonald, Chief of Marion Police; Bill Collins, former Chief of Police and current Mayor; and Sheriff Matt Bayles, highlighting their social connections and past collaborations. These relationships are cited as further complicating the judge’s ability to remain impartial.

The affidavit references Anderson’s previous role as a defense attorney in cases investigated by Damron himself, raising questions about potential bias. 

According to Ohio law, a judge’s disqualification is warranted if there is a reason to question their impartiality, whether due to bias, prejudices, or personal relationships. 

Danton argues that the extent of Judge Anderson’s affiliations necessitates his recusal to maintain public confidence in the judiciary.

The Affidavit was filed on Monday and arrives shortly before Damron’s next court hearing, with no further hearings currently scheduled.

 Damron requests that the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Ohio assign a different judge to the case to ensure fairness in the proceedings.

Marion County Now will continue to cover this developing story.